Born in Shaker Heights, Ohio, McElroy moved to New York City in May 1990 after earning his BFA in Theatre from Carnegie Mellon University. He made his Broadway debut in The High Rollers Social and Pleasure Club. He has since appeared in numerous productions, both on and off-Broadway, and in 2004 was nominated for a Tony Award for Best Featured Actor in a Musical for Big River. He has also been nominated for Drama Desk Awards for Violet and Big River. In 1995, McElroy appeared in the premiere performance of John Adams' opera I Was Looking at the Ceiling and Then I Saw the Sky in Berkeley, California.
In 1999, McElroy became the founder and director of the Broadway Inspirational Voices,[3] a diverse, non-denominational gospel choir made up of Broadway singers. He currently teaches in the New Studio on Broadway at New York University's Tisch School of the Arts.[4]
Stage credits[edit]
Broadway[edit]
Year
Title
Role
Notes[5]
1992
The High Rollers Social and Pleasure Club
Sorcerer
Broadway debut, Original Broadway production
1993
The Who's Tommy
Hawker
Original Broadway production
1997
Rent
Tom Collins
Replacement
Street Corner Symphony
N/A
Vocal arranger
2000
The Wild Party
Oscar D'Armano
Original Broadway production
2003
Big River
Jim
Revival
2010
Next To Normal
Dr. Madden/ Dr. Fine
Replacement
2016
Disaster!
N/A
Vocal arranger
2017
Sunday In The Park With George
Ensemble
Revival
Off-Broadway[edit]
Violet (1998) – Flick
Hair (2001) – Hud
Some Men (2007) – Marcus and others
Workshops[edit]
Spring Awakening (2001) – Masked Man
PandA committee (2011)
Filmography[edit]
Film[edit]
Year
Title
Role
Notes
1995
Stonewall
Princess Ernestine
2005
Romance & Cigarettes
Ten Commandments Priest
2008
Rent: Filmed Live on Broadway
Tom Collins
Television[edit]
Year
Title
Role
Notes
1999
Spin City
Gym manager
Episode: These Shoes Were Made for Cheatin'
2001
Santa, Baby!
Voice
TV Movie
Great Performances
Self
Season 28, My Favorite Broadway: The Love Songs
2005
Judge / Captain / Crook
Season 32, Leonard Bernstein's 'Candide' with the New York Philharmonic
^Pogrebin, Robin (12 November 2001). "VOLUNTEERING; Broadway Stars Spread The Gospel at Benefits". The New York Times. p. 25. Retrieved 23 September 2011. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
^"about". broadwayinspirationalvoices.org. Retrieved 10 December 2020.
^"MICHAEL MCELROY". tisch.nyu.ed. Retrieved 10 December 2020.